pumpkin muffins with a cream chese middle and red muffin liners

Okay, people, put down the PSL and listen up! The second the leaves start to turn and a chill begins to fill the air, we know the craving for pumpkin spice everything hits hard. If pumpkin spice is synonymous with Starbucks’ iconic Pumpkin Spice Latte for you, then good news—you can not only re-create the warming drink at home, but I’ve also developed a copycat recipe for another beloved Starbucks’ fall snack: their Pumpkin Cream Cheese Muffins.

Get ready to ditch takeout and whip up these delicious muffins that are so spot on, you’ll swear they came straight from your favorite barista. We’re talking moist, fall-spiced pumpkin perfection with a dreamy, creamy center that’ll have you saying, “Starbucks who?” Trust me, these muffins are about to become your new fall (or any season, for that matter) baking obsession.

Made these muffins? Rate and review them below!

pumpkin muffins with a cream chese middle and red muffin linerspinterest

PHOTO: LINDA PUGLIESE; FOOD STYLING: MAKINZE GORE